Conservatives denounced left-wing bias among the news media and elite thinkers for decades before acting to alter the landscape. By founding Fox News and think tanks like the Heritage Foundation and the Cato Institute, they expanded the reach of conservative voices in America — and counterbalanced what was once a liberal tilt.
Now, some conservatives are following a similar playbook to change higher education. Hillsdale College, the small, conservative Christian school in southern Michigan, has expanded its Washington, D.C., campus to try to reach more students. Conservatives have also claimed victories over more established institutions: After the College Board altered its Advanced Placement course in African American studies this month, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis suggested his administration had driven the changes.
But DeSantis has aimed broader than the College Board. He recently announced proposals to transform Florida’s public universities. He has called for an end to diversity programs and for weaker tenure protections for professors. And he installed conservatives as leaders of New College of Florida, a small public school in Sarasota.
“The new leadership has said explicitly that they want to change the ideology of the school,” said my colleague Patricia Mazzei, The Times’s Miami bureau chief. “It’s become a test case.”
Today’s newsletter will look at what DeSantis is doing — and why he may have a hard time succeeding.
Higher education faculty is predominantly liberal. On this point, there is not much debate among experts. About 60 percent of undergraduate teaching faculty identify as liberal or far left, compared with about 12 percent who identify as conservative or far right. The gap has grown over the past few decades.
Why does it exist? There is less agreement on that question. It could be a self-fulfilling prophecy: Because colleges are viewed as liberal institutions, fewer conservatives strive to join their staff. Or it could be that faculty hiring boards discriminate against conservative applicants. And since college graduates are more likely to identify as liberal, the pipeline for conservative professors is narrower.
What is the impact? Surprisingly, some studies suggest that college classes may actually moderate students’ views. As liberal as they may be, professors generally encourage students to engage with different, and sometimes conservative, viewpoints. “There’s a tendency for movement conservatives to overstate the problem,” said Jon Shields, a conservative and a professor of government at Claremont McKenna College.
Still, professors’ left-wing bias most likely leads to some self-censorship by students and faculty and limits political discussions on campuses. A lack of interaction with conservative mentors could also push students to fill the void with more extreme right-wing sources, Shields said.
There is a harm to progressive students too, said Amy Binder, a sociologist at the University of California, San Diego. In her research, conservative students told her that they were constantly challenged by liberal teachers and students, helping them sharpen their abilities to think about opposing ideas and debate them. Progressive students generally get less of that experience.
The public appears to agree that this is a problem: A majority have said that campus politics lean toward one direction and that there’s too much concern about protecting students from views they might find offensive, a 2019 Pew Research Center poll found.
So DeSantis is rallying not only his core supporters with this issue but potentially swing voters as well.
DeSantis nonetheless may struggle to accomplish his goal of transforming higher education. It is a sprawling sector where many people with power — namely, professors — have tenure and cannot easily be replaced.
The dynamics are different with higher education than in the news media. Conservatives did not have to take over CNN or MSNBC to alter the balance of coverage; they simply created Fox News and built an audience there. But a single conservative university can serve only so many students. Conservatives need to change the culture of perhaps thousands of campuses without scaring away students and their parents — an onerous task.
DeSantis is pursuing two paths. He is taking steps to change major tenets of higher education. His proposal to weaken tenure, which the legislature must approve, could make it easier for his appointees to fire liberal teachers. But those professors would have to be replaced. There may not be enough conservatives for all of those jobs, especially as the pool of potential hires — college graduates — has shifted further left over time.
The second part of DeSantis’s push is narrower: transforming New College of Florida, which has nearly 700 students. Its new leadership hopes to turn the school into a model for a conservative education by, for example, developing a new core curriculum. But scaling that model statewide or nationally would be a much bigger undertaking.
Of course, even if DeSantis fails to overhaul higher education, his efforts could have another benefit for him: They could give his expected presidential campaign a boost in Republican primaries that are likely to get very contentious.
Related: If DeSantis runs, he would start the campaign in an unusually strong position for someone who has never held national office — similar to Barack Obama in 2008, Ronald Reagan in 1976 and Ted Kennedy in 1980, as Nate Cohn explains.
THE LATEST NEWS
Other Big Stories
Navigating a child’s unimaginable illness means learning to talk about hard things as a family, Sarah Wildman writes.
Covid upended American schools. It’s time to reinvent them, David Brooks argues.
There’s reason for optimism about the U.S. economy, Paul Krugman says on “The Ezra Klein Show.”
Layoff vlogs: These tech workers lost their jobs — and then they went viral on TikTok.
Green thumb: Here’s how to pick the right houseplant for you.
Modern Love: Does divorce have to feel shameful?
Advice from Wirecutter: Ditch your air mattress for a folding one.
Lives Lived: Tim McCarver was a solid Major League Baseball catcher, but he became better known as a Hall of Fame broadcaster who often correctly predicted plays. He died at 81.
SPORTS NEWS FROM THE ATHLETIC
Spring stories: Jayson Stark surveyed 29 baseball insiders about the most important news of the 2023 season. Leading the way: Shohei Ohtani.
Women’s soccer: The U.S. national team topped Canada, 2-0, in their opening match of the SheBelieves Cup yesterday.
N.B.A. Draft: This class is strong largely because of the top two players: Scoot Henderson and Victor Wembanyama.
ARTS AND IDEAS
A scary plushie
You may have seen him staring at you from the window of a tourist shop, or hanging from a booth at the county fair. His eyes are bloodshot, and his mouth is stretched into a hungry grin. His name is Huggy Wuggy, and he has become unavoidable — even if most people don’t know where he’s from.
Huggy Wuggy is the primary villain of the indie horror video game Poppy Playtime, which is set in an abandoned toy factory. But he has become more famous as a plush toy. Vendors found that children were oddly drawn to his creepy smile, and knockoff toys began popping up around the world.
“Most of our fans have never played our game,” said Zach Belanger, the chief executive of the video game studio that developed Poppy Playtime.
PLAY, WATCH, EAT
What to Cook